Design Edge Canada Website of the Year - Canadian Business Press
News
17 September 2009
IKEA tells Pylon to pack-up campaign

TORONTO—To announce it’s recent move to Liberty Village in Toronto, 12-year-old design studio Pylon launched a mini campaign in a visual language that parodies ubiquitous Scandinavian furniture retailer IKEA.

Its humorous, black-and-white mailer mimicked an IKEA instruction manual by describing how to build a pylon. The booklet also directed people to the agency’s microsite and reminded them to update their address book.

IKEA lawyers ask Pylon to cease and desist
Pylon's moving notice was in breach of IKEA's brand

IKEA, however, didn’t find it very amusing. Five days after the campaign launched, Pylon received a cease and desist letter from its lawyers, who, as it turns out, were on Pylon’s mailing list and received the package directly.

“Everyone uses IKEA when they’re moving. We weren't being detrimental to IKEA, we love IKEA,” says Pylon president Scott Christie, who adds he spent $10,000 on new office furniture at the modern home furnishings mecca.

(Interestingly, IKEA has recently come under fire from designers who are aghast that it changed its catalogue text font from Futura to Verdana, a typeface designed for the web.)

Christie had seen other design agencies spoof logos in a fun way to much success, such as U.K.’s now defunct The Designers Republic.

In this instance, however, IKEA perceived Pylon’s use of its brand characteristics as exploitation for Pylon’s own commercial gain.

Christie says his story should be a warning to other designers: “If they’re thinking of parodying a well known, recognized brand, [don't] do it.”

This is not the first time that Pylon has been reprimanded for trademark infringement. Several years ago it designed a cover for Canadian Underwriter magazine about blood banks. It featured a red cross draining blood. According to the International Committee of the Red Cross in Geneva, which called the magazine, you’re not allowed to use its symbol without permission. Contact: pylon.ca

1. Anonymous
17 September 2009 at 3:16 PM
Love the concept. Ikea should focus more on their Verdana vs Futura problem and less about Pylon, who produce amazing work.
2. Anonymous
25 September 2009 at 4:24 PM
I thought Ikea had a sense of humour.
3. Anonymous
29 September 2009 at 2:53 PM
It's time to think of more original ideas Pylon.
4. Anonymous
29 September 2009 at 3:56 PM
Ikea's reaction seems like the behavior of a mindless corporate bully. If Pylon sold mass market furniture there would be a valid infringement case, but Pylon is a small graphic design studio making a visual pun for a tiny market. This does not compete with ikea's interests, nor does it disparage them in any way. From Ikea's marketing point of view, pylon's behaviour is highly desirable. It's a kind of viral marketing created by a loyal customer. Ikea here seems to me to be peeing in their own well and alienating someone who'd be a good business partner.

It's unfortunate to see that the red cross believes they have the exclusive rights to a symbol they themselves stole from Sumerian mandelas, Roman crosses, the Christian cross, Swiss national flag and "+" symbol of mathematics. They cannot own the last several thousand years of cultural history.

There is nothing deceptive about using a red cross to connote health care. There is something deceptive about painting a red cross on a truck carrying armed men intent on surprising and killing civilians, but I don't expect a mindless corporation is serious enough to bother doing anything to stop real infractions like that.
5. Anonymous
29 September 2009 at 4:53 PM
If I post a picture of my ikea bookshelves on my blog and say I love them, will Ikea's lawyers come after me too?

Umbra, Pottery Barn, Crate&Barrel, made.ca and Design within Reach suddenly seem so welcoming.

Name:
Anonymous
Your Name Please!

Comment:
Editor's note: We reserve the right to edit and/or delete comments that we consider inappropriate, defamatory or malicious. Keep your comments constructive.
Comment Copy Please!

Click to refresh
Please fill in the 4-character Captcha!
Archives
Most Recent Comment
Anonymous says:
Who determines who does or doesn't have 'the credentials' anyway? The 'credentials' police??
...
Fontest
 
 
Calling all typophiles! Enter our font contest and you could win a prize
FREE Subscription

January/February 2012

FREE Newsletter

Sign up now for our free news and jobs email bulletin

Live from Twitter